4

I am new to Ethereum. I know gas limit and gas price well. but still confused in

  1. when sending a transaction to run a deployed contract, does Ethereum suggest an estimation of how much gas limit is needed to complete the transaction?

  2. if so, How accurate is that estimation? In other words, will it always be completed successfully if only the estimation gas is being paid?

  3. if no, How can i know/predict the gas needed?

  4. For miners when they got a transaction to run a contract, are they able to know how much will it take to finish the execution (know how much gas limit (computational steps) this transaction costs) or they just know how much is the gas price?.

  5. How validators verify that miners executed a contract correctly? will they re-execute it again or just validate the block without running contracts?

I tried to figure these out, but still not be able.

Thanks

3

Geth does estimate the gas cost of a transaction, but theoretically no one--not geth, not the miners, nor anyone else--can know the gas cost of a transaction before it executed while creating a block. This is because something else could happen in a block before the transaction is executed (or even in the same block), thus changing the result that geth got when it made the estimate. It's even possible that geth made the estimate on a block that didn't even make it into the canonical blockchain.

Which brings the second point. geth gets its estimate by simulating the transaction itself, based on the latest block. There is essentially no other way to do so. This is called the Halting Problem, if you want to look it up, and it's why gas exists in the first place.

However, in most situations, sending the estimate is sufficient. It's even possible, in (IMHO) the majority of situations, to determine how much gas a transaction could ever possibly consume, and then use that.

  • Thanks Matthew for the useful answer. I have another question that i just raised. I know that each operation in the EVM consumes a specific amount of gas. How Ethereum pre-defined the cost of each operation (e.g., ADD costs 3 gas)? is it based on the time it takes to process the transaction? or is it just an assumption? – MWH Mar 23 '17 at 20:54
  • You might want to ask that as as separate question, as comments aren't really designed to answer that. – Matthew Schmidt Mar 24 '17 at 18:15

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.