2

Examples of digital assets that can be tokenized as NFTs are:

  • crypto art (.jpg or .png file stored off-chain)
  • game weapons or characters

Examples of physical assets that can be tokenized as NFTs are:

  • a house
  • stocks
  • car

All of the above are stored off-chain. That is, not even the tokenized digital assets are usually stored on the blockchain due to costs incurred, just like how a house and car cannot be stored on the blockchain.

What other digital and physical assets not listed above can be tokenized that actually can be stored on-chain economically?

2

You are asking two questions really:

  1. What can be stored on-chain
  2. What can be stored economically

Let's address them separately.

What can be stored on-chain?

The ERC-721 Metadata Extension (ERC721Metadata) and ERC-1155 Metadata Extension (ERC1155Metadata_URI) both specify that a URI can be attached to an NFT but the specifications are slightly different:

ERC-721 states that this URI:

"may point to a JSON file that conforms to the "ERC721 Metadata JSON Schema".

ERC-1155 states that this URI:

"MUST point to a JSON file that conforms to the "ERC-1155 Metadata URI JSON Schema"

According to these specifications, the ERC-721 allows ANY kind of metadata. This includes URIs that are NOT JSON objects, such as urn.us.pa.state.identity.drivers-license.213049873409 which could be a URN to represent a specific licensed driver in Pennsylvania, USA.

ERC-721 also allows URI data such as including a JSON (perhaps following the ERC- 721 Metadata JSON Schema) file on-chain or any other file.

Strictly speaking, ERC-1155 only supports JSON objects and it only supports a URI that will "point" to that JSON object file. You might consider this to mean that only URLs are valid as metadata on ERC-1155.

In summary: you can store JSON objects and any arbitrary files/data using the ERC-721 Metadata Extension. You cannot store files on chain using the ERC-1155 Metadata Extension (if following the standard strictly).

What can be stored economically?

Ethereum Mainnet is currently very expensive. As of 2021-02-25, storing a megabyte of data on Ethereum Mainnet might cost around USD 10,000 to USD 100,000. This is the way many people are quoting this figure.

Of course nobody is storing these types of files at this cost.

But, you could easily store megabytes of data on POA, Hyperledger Burrow, Ropsten and other networks. I consider all of these to be "Ethereum" (while not "Ethereum® Mainnet") and the cost will be several (many?) orders of magnitude cheaper. And this might be acceptable for your use case.

1
  • thanks, all valid and alot of leads I will have to read up on. your answer to what can be stored on-chain is more technical (Ethereum protocol-centric) than I intended. what I meant are "things" in real life, or on our computer, that we can tokenize, that were not already included in the list. Basically a more exhaustive brainstorming of all objects, artifacts, papers that could be tokenized – user610620 Feb 28 at 21:03
1

Ask yourself: "What useful data do I use in my everyday life?" That question leads to the following answers:

  • Proof of Identification (Driver's license, Passport, Photo ID's)
  • Insurance Documents (Auto insurance, Personal property)
  • Health Information (Doctor's Papers, Fitness Data)

Those are just a couple of examples that I came up with with that question. If you think about tokenization as a way to store data, I bet you'd be able to come up with more ideas.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.