7

I just did my first transfer of ETH from Coinbase to Kraken, to see how it would work.

I transferred 1 ETH, and Coinbase indicated that the transfer charge (the gas) would be .00042 ETH (as I would have expected). The total transfer out of Coinbase was 1.00042.

I expected 1 ETH to arrive in my Kraken account. But, only .99938 ETH arrived. At some point, .00062 ETH was "lost."

Since the gas was already covered, Coinbase indicated that there was no additional fee on their end, and Kraken indicated there was no additional fee on their end, I can't figure out where the .00062 ETH went.

Any thoughts?

  • If you can provide the transaction ids for the above, you should be able to trace it that way. – Adam Dossa May 19 '17 at 23:11
  • Thanks for the response! Here is the Tx hash for the transaction...but, I can't interpret the information well enough to determine where the fees went... 0x3d2218451e3b77218d1be91589b8be6832faa0a53d55f40ebd6f58d72e63d26c – Jason Scott May 22 '17 at 21:45
  • That transaction doesn't show up in etherscan.io - is there a typo perhaps? Maybe post a link to the transaction on etherscan.io. – Adam Dossa May 23 '17 at 19:53
  • Appreciate your help! Here you go: etherscan.io/tx/… – Jason Scott May 23 '17 at 20:58
  • How did you go about transferring form coinbase to kraken? I am new to this coin business and coinbase closed my account for NO reason. I want to transfer to KRaken but don't know how. – Gus Dec 5 '17 at 21:24
8

I see what happened.

1ETH was transferred: from 0x2bF0011e4da5a841CE9459c0995Bb2646c4f1D21 (coinbase) to 0xd08436533f63b1342fB89198F963acD8589657AE (intermediary address) with a gas cost of (21000 * 0.00000002)ETH https://etherscan.io/tx/0x3d2218451e3b77218d1be91589b8be6832faa0a53d55f40ebd6f58d72e63d26c

then, from this intermediary address, there was a transfer of 0.99938038ETH: from 0xd08436533f63b1342fB89198F963acD8589657AE (intermediary address) to 0xFa52274DD61E1643d2205169732f29114BC240b3 (kraken smart contract address?) with a gas cost of (30981 * 0.00000002) = 0.00061962ETH and 0.99938038 + 0.00061962 = 1ETH https://etherscan.io/tx/0xef5b7451006a6315604c82e4088e298a57105b7d6f1b728f74387efea55eaac0

So in other words, your transaction from coinbase to kraken hopped through an intermediary address. This hop had a gas cost equal to the amount you're missing from your original 1ETH.

As to what the intermediary contract is - I'm not sure...

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.