4

I understand the Ropsten testnet was partly necessary because of some broken replay-protection measures on Morden. So what's different for Ropsten?

Is the nonce simply incremented by a smaller number than Morden was?

Looking at the genesis block, it looks like the nonce value is set to 0x42, is that the nonce offset? So after a mainnet account has more than 66 transactions, its testnet transactions are replayable on the mainnet?

This doesn't sound ideal, but if that's the answer, please let me know!

4

Ropsten clients such as Geth and Parity use EIP 155 Simple replay attack protection to protect against Ropsten transactions being replayed on mainnet.

Excerpt (EIP 155 has an actual example):

v = CHAIN_ID * 2 + 35 or v = CHAIN_ID * 2 + 36, then when computing the hash of a transaction for purposes of signing or recovering, instead of hashing only the first six elements (ie. nonce, gasprice, startgas, to, value, data), hash nine elements, with v replaced by CHAIN_ID, r = 0 and s = 0. The currently existing signature scheme using v = 27 and v = 28 remains valid and continues to operate under the same rules as it does now.

CHAIN_ID for Ropsten is 3.

A Ropsten transaction must be crafted to the rules of EIP 155 to get replay protection. If a wallet implements EIP 155, it can issue unlimited transactions which are protected from replay attacks. If a wallet does not implement EIP 155, transactions it creates can be replayed on other networks (because they are still valid transactions and is what is meant by the last sentence in the above excerpt).

Briefly, for implementing EIP 155 in Ropsten, hash 9 elements (instead of 6) and use 41 or 42 for v.


The nonce in Geth's Ropsten genesis file is not related to replay protection: see What does each genesis.json parameter mean? As noted here, Parity has a separate genesis file for Ropsten and Parity would call that (pre-EIP155 replay-protection nonce) the accountStartNonce.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.